Skip to content
eBook Charts
US
Dialectic.

Dialectic.

English Studies in Canada

$5.99

Buy on Amazon View on Apple Books

Prefer it in print? See every format on Amazon →

Price on Apple Books. Amazon’s price may differ.

Read a lot? Try Kindle+ * · Compare subscriptions

Published
Genres
Professional & TechnicalEducation

Description

Most accounts of the English word dialectic duly report that it enters the English language in the 14th century as a general word for "logic" and more specifically for "the art of dispute by question and answer" and that it comes via the Old French dialectique and the Latin dialectica from the Greek expression dialektike (techne), meaning "(art) of conversation or discourse." What is not reported, and yet would be worth recalling, is the etymological path by which a matter of "conversation" first becomes a matter of "logic!' The Greek word dialektike is the feminine nominal form of the adjective dialektikos, meaning "conversational" or "characteristic of discourse:' Dialektikos derives in turn from the feminine noun, dialektos, meaning principally "discourse," "conversation, "ordinary talk" but also "articulate speech as opposed to mere sound," "the language of a country" "a particular dialect," (dialektos being the mot of the English word dialect), "a specific local word or expression," and even "a particular style of speaking or enunciating:' The noun dialektos derives from the deponent verb, dialegomai, ring "to converse" or "to discuss," (from whence comes the English dialogue), as well as "to associate or hold converse or have dealings with," "to speak a particular language or dialect" and euphemistically "to have intercourse with:' Dialegomaiis constructed from the prefix dta, meaning "between," "across; "through," and the root, legran. Legein means not only "to say" "to speak," "to talk," "to name," "to mean" but also (and if Heidegger is to be believed, "just as early and even more originally" cf. Logos) "to gather together," "to lay down or to lay before us," and so to be able "to pick up," "to choose," "to reckon"what has been "let lie together before us.' This etymology suggests on the one hand that dialektike has its basis in ordinary discourse as fundamental to our way of being and being-together, and of ordering, accounting for, and making sense of things; and yet on the other hand that it emerges as distinct from ordinary talk precisely in being the an of discourse. Ordinary talk serves a variety of purposes, including the sheer pleasure of talking for its own sake. Its order and intelligibility typically depend on any number of accidental conditions and connections, including factors peculiar to particular languages, idioms, interlocutors and discursive situations. As an "art," however, dialektike would constitute a form of discursive knowledge or competence, distinct from intuitive ability (physis) or mere chance (tyche), that admits of being systematically ordered and articulated and thereby of being taught and applied. Likewise, it would transcend the vicissitudes, accidents, local variations and changing rules of propriety that variously determine the multiplicity of particular discourses. The order and intelligibility of dialektike would not then be contingent or adventitious but a necessary order of reasons in principle accessible to and binding for all possible interlocutors across all possible discourses.