Enshittification — Personal Reflection
$75.00
Comprar en Amazon Ver en Apple Books¿Lo prefieres en papel? Todos los formatos en Amazon →
Precio en Apple Books. En Amazon puede ser otro.
- Publicado
Descripción
20 Lessons I Learned About Platform Power, Digital Rights, and Resistance — Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It
From the introduction to this independent reflection
Most people have had the same small experience this decade: an app or a website that used to work well slowly stops doing so. The search results fill with sponsored items. The feed shows less of the friends you chose and more of whatever somebody paid to put there. The device you bought needs a part only its maker will sell. It is easy to treat each case as bad luck, or as a failure of your own patience. Cory Doctorow’s book Enshittification offers a different reading: the pattern is shared, it has a mechanism, and it was produced by decisions that can be changed.
This is a reflection inspired by that book. It is not a summary and it is not a substitute for reading it, because the book is a long, evidence-laden argument and I have not read all of it. What I read was the Introduction and a long case-study excerpt about Facebook, both published by the book’s publisher or with its permission. I also read the publisher’s description, a number of reviews, one extended critical review, and a blog post in which Doctorow answers the complaint that his book is short on individual solutions. I did not read the rest of the chapters. So wherever I describe what Doctorow argues, I mean what those materials show, and I try to say so in the sentence itself.
That brings me to the method of these pages. Because the book is nonfiction and makes claims about companies, laws and history, I want to keep two things apart. One is what the author reports or argues: his account of how platforms change over time, his explanation of why now, his proposed remedies. The other is what I think about it, which is a different category and a more modest one. I am not an economist or a lawyer, and I will not pretend that my agreement settles a factual dispute. Where I find an argument persuasive I will say why, and where I find it incomplete I will say that too, helped by critics who have read the whole thing.
The central claim, as the Introduction presents it, is that the word enshittification is more than a joke about things getting worse. It is offered as a theory of how an online service decays, how the decay spreads, and what to do about it. The author says the cause is not an iron law of economics but specific policy choices made by identifiable people. If that is right, it is a hopeful thought, because choices can be unmade. If it is only partly right, the interesting question becomes how much of the problem sits in policy and how much in other things.
The three themes of the subtitle, platform power, digital rights and resistance, organize the lessons. The first chapters look at the word, the experience behind it, and the stages the book describes. The middle chapters look at why this is happening now, what it means to own something digital, and the people who work inside the companies. The later chapters take up what ordinary readers can and cannot do alone, how collective efforts work, how to weigh a passionate argument, and what I would carry from all of it into my own small decisions.
One practical note. The book’s language is blunt and often profane, and I have chosen a quieter register. I have also avoided any technical instructions: where the book touches on modifying devices or software, the law differs between places, and I treat the subject as a question of principle, not a how-to. Everyday examples here are imagined, and I label them.
Read the twenty lessons and consider the questions in your own life.
From the introduction to this independent reflection
Most people have had the same small experience this decade: an app or a website that used to work well slowly stops doing so. The search results fill with sponsored items. The feed shows less of the friends you chose and more of whatever somebody paid to put there. The device you bought needs a part only its maker will sell. It is easy to treat each case as bad luck, or as a failure of your own patience. Cory Doctorow’s book Enshittification offers a different reading: the pattern is shared, it has a mechanism, and it was produced by decisions that can be changed.
This is a reflection inspired by that book. It is not a summary and it is not a substitute for reading it, because the book is a long, evidence-laden argument and I have not read all of it. What I read was the Introduction and a long case-study excerpt about Facebook, both published by the book’s publisher or with its permission. I also read the publisher’s description, a number of reviews, one extended critical review, and a blog post in which Doctorow answers the complaint that his book is short on individual solutions. I did not read the rest of the chapters. So wherever I describe what Doctorow argues, I mean what those materials show, and I try to say so in the sentence itself.
That brings me to the method of these pages. Because the book is nonfiction and makes claims about companies, laws and history, I want to keep two things apart. One is what the author reports or argues: his account of how platforms change over time, his explanation of why now, his proposed remedies. The other is what I think about it, which is a different category and a more modest one. I am not an economist or a lawyer, and I will not pretend that my agreement settles a factual dispute. Where I find an argument persuasive I will say why, and where I find it incomplete I will say that too, helped by critics who have read the whole thing.
The central claim, as the Introduction presents it, is that the word enshittification is more than a joke about things getting worse. It is offered as a theory of how an online service decays, how the decay spreads, and what to do about it. The author says the cause is not an iron law of economics but specific policy choices made by identifiable people. If that is right, it is a hopeful thought, because choices can be unmade. If it is only partly right, the interesting question becomes how much of the problem sits in policy and how much in other things.
The three themes of the subtitle, platform power, digital rights and resistance, organize the lessons. The first chapters look at the word, the experience behind it, and the stages the book describes. The middle chapters look at why this is happening now, what it means to own something digital, and the people who work inside the companies. The later chapters take up what ordinary readers can and cannot do alone, how collective efforts work, how to weigh a passionate argument, and what I would carry from all of it into my own small decisions.
One practical note. The book’s language is blunt and often profane, and I have chosen a quieter register. I have also avoided any technical instructions: where the book touches on modifying devices or software, the law differs between places, and I treat the subject as a question of principle, not a how-to. Everyday examples here are imagined, and I label them.
Read the twenty lessons and consider the questions in your own life.