Books like The Hollow
Connelly fans who want that slow, stubborn return to an old case will find plenty here. These eight novels pair buried histories with methodical detectives and a steady undercurrent of unease.
1. The Cabin
Jørn Lier Horst & Anne Bruce · £0.99
A decades-old disappearance reopens in a patient, methodical investigation, with a veteran detective whose quiet persistence drives the story towards danger.
Buy on Amazon2. For Reasons Unknown
Michael Wood · £3.99
A returning detective digs into a long-buried massacre, with past and present bleeding together in a sombre, unsettling way that rewards careful reading.
Buy on Amazon3. False Witness
John Carson · £0.99
A seasoned DCI goes back to a killer he never caught, offering a tense, weary mood and the lingering sense that old mistakes are not finished.
Buy on Amazon4. Her Last Kiss
Lisa Regan · £2.99
A cold case resurfaces after thirteen years, and a determined detective faces a killer whose return reopens wounds nobody wanted to revisit.
Buy on Amazon5. Hidden Scars
Angela Marsons · £3.99
A suspicious death inside a Victorian clinic uncovers institutional secrets, handled by a dogged detective whose grit suits readers of gritty, closed-institution mysteries.
Buy on Amazon6. The Lantern Men
Elly Griffiths · £5.49
A forensic expert is pulled back to the Norfolk marshes to find bodies hidden by a convicted murderer, with atmosphere that lingers long after the last page.
Buy on Amazon7. Every Little Lie
Dandy Smith · £3.99
Years after a friend's murder, messages from the dead woman's phone unsettle a narrator whose version of events cannot quite be trusted.
Buy on Amazon8. The Mirror Man
Lars Kepler · £0.99
A detective hunts a killer after a child's body is found, with a single unreliable witness adding doubt and a chilling, claustrophobic tension throughout.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 14 Nov 2026.