Books like Whose Body?
Readers who enjoyed Sayers' gentleman sleuth and tidy puzzles will find plenty to savour here, from village whodunnits to a witty 1930s London mystery. Each pick offers clues, a sharp sense of place and an amateur who refuses to let the police have all the fun.
1. The Locked Room
Holly Hepburn · €2.99
A 1930s London setting, a clever clerk and a diamond theft from a locked room offer the period charm and fair-play clueing that Sayers readers prize.
Buy on Amazon2. The Mysterious Affair Of Judith Potts
Robert Thorogood · €1.49
A crossword-setter turned amateur investigator, with witty friends and old secrets resurfacing, gives a gently comic English puzzle with a cosy, clue-filled feel.
Buy on Amazon3. A Carol and a Killing
Richard Coles · €7.99
A village amateur sleuth who suspects foul play where others see an accident, with gentle humour and a seasonal English setting.
Buy on Amazon4. The Dogwalkers' Detective Agency
Michael Hogan · €0.99
An everyday amateur sleuth working alongside his dog, sniffing out clues in a sleepy coastal town with warm humour and a tight local cast.
Buy on Amazon5. Mydworth Mysteries - Secrets on the Cote d'Azur
Matthew Costello & Neil Richards · €4.99
Two amateur investigators drawn into a blackmail case in a 1920s-style setting, with elegant period detail and a cosy, old-fashioned tone.
Buy on Amazon6. The Archy McNally Series Volume One
Lawrence Sanders · €16.99
A playboy private investigator untangling murder among the wealthy elite brings the same urbane wit and gentleman-detective swagger as Sayers' hero.
Buy on Amazon7. Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel
Lucy Foley · €19.99
A snowbound hotel where every guest has a motive delivers a classic Golden Age puzzle with a sharp, suspenseful edge and plenty of suspects.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 18 Nov 2026.