Books like When He Was Wicked
For readers who loved the witty, slow-unfolding tension of When He Was Wicked, this selection leans towards friends-turned-lovers and second chances. Each pick offers warmth, banter and a sense that old feelings are finally being faced.
1. People We Meet On Vacation
Emily Henry · €5.99
A decade-spanning friendship told through yearly trips, with the same warmth, humour and slow realisation of feelings that build beneath the surface.
Buy on Amazon2. Love and Other Words
Christina Lauren · €5.49
Two former friends reunite as adults and confront the past that pulled them apart, with tender emotion and a deep sense of longing.
Buy on Amazon3. My Once and Future Duke
Caroline Linden · €2.49
A card-sharp heroine and a wagering duke trade risky bets in a witty historical romance with sparkling, playful tension.
Buy on Amazon4. Someone Like You
Lauren Layne · €4.49
A playboy's hidden heartbreak softens into a flirtatious, emotional romance, offering the same reluctant vulnerability beneath a charming surface.
Buy on Amazon5. It's Different This Time
Joss Richard · €0.99
Two former friends forced to share a New York property must face unfinished business, bringing a heartfelt, emotionally honest second-chance story.
Buy on Amazon6. Hello, Stranger
Katherine Center · €5.49
A friendship-driven romance with a warm, reflective tone, following a woman rebuilding her life while navigating unexpected feelings for two men.
Buy on Amazon7. The Great Ex-Scape
Jo Watson · €2.99
A heartbroken woman meets a fellow traveller and the pair agree to help each other heal, with lightly comic, tender friendship at its core.
Buy on Amazon8. Nothing To Lose: A Lesbian Romance
Clare Lydon · €7.99
A grumpy tenant and a cheerful mayor discover that opposites attract, giving a witty, cosy take on enemies becoming close friends.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 20 Nov 2026.