Books like The Play
Here are eight picks for readers who loved the banter, close quarters and slow-building heat of The Play. Each one pairs a hook of forced proximity or pretend romance with the warmth and humour that made that book so easy to devour.
1. Pike
Brenda Rothert · €4.49
A wary single mum and a goalie with a reckless bet offer the same sharp, funny clash of wills and grown-up feelings that makes this kind of romance so addictive.
Buy on Amazon2. Time to Shine
Rachel Reid · €7.99
A reserved backup goalie sharing a flat with a charming winger gives you cosy winter days, shared holidays and friendship slowly turning into something sweeter.
Buy on Amazon3. Icebreaker
Hannah Grace · €5.49
A competitive skater forced to share a rink with a hockey captain brings the same bickering tension, witty protests and an easy, playful tone.
Buy on Amazon4. Two for Holding
S.B. Barnes · €5.99
An icy hockey captain and a flamboyant new teammate must learn to trust each other, with a slow burn that rewards patience and a strong emotional core.
Buy on Amazon5. You’re My Cherry Pie
Athena Carstairs · €4.49
A fake relationship with a best friend's infuriating brother turns playful banter into real affection, with the lighthearted, teasing energy of a classic campus-style romance.
Buy on Amazon6. Funny Story
Emily Henry · €6.99
Two opposites pretending to date, with a shared history and plenty of awkward, funny moments, deliver the same mix of wit and rising chemistry.
Buy on Amazon7. The Game Plan
Laura Carter · €2.99
A hockey star and his publicist agree to a fake marriage after a Las Vegas mishap, offering a light, comic romance with sports banter and growing feelings.
Buy on Amazon8. Love Story
Lindsey Kelk · €5.99
A secretive romance author and a cocky creative director clash on a countryside trip, giving a witty, sharply observed romance with forced closeness and plenty of sparks.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 17 Nov 2026.