Books like Protecting What’s Mine
If you loved the cosy small-town pull and grumpy-sunshine banter of Lucy Score's world, these picks bring that same warmth, bickering chemistry and forced-together settings. Each one offers a fresh pairing, with a mix of rural romance, sports and light comedy.
1. Old-Fashioned Rancher
Audrey Bell · €2.99
A grumpy divorced rancher softens around a cheerful florist in a small Colorado town, with a warm, cosy tone and a slow thaw.
Buy on Amazon2. Lost and Lassoed
Lyla Sage · €5.99
Bickering rivals are forced into a workload crisis in a small town, delivering the same sparring humour and reluctant closeness you enjoyed.
Buy on Amazon3. Heartless
Elsie Silver · €6.99
A nanny on a Western ranch falls for her gruff, hardworking single-dad boss over a summer, with heartfelt emotion and easy small-town charm.
Buy on Amazon4. The Pumpkin Spice Café
Laurie Gilmore · €1.49
A cheerful city girl takes over a small-town café and tests a grumpy farmer's patience, offering cosy, lighthearted romance with plenty of bite.
Buy on Amazon5. All Change
Pippa Nixon · €2.99
A restless stuntwoman meets a devoted small-town firefighter whose steady warmth challenges her refusal to settle, capturing that firefighter-and-small-town feel.
Buy on Amazon6. Pike
Brenda Rothert · €4.49
A wary single mum and a hockey goalie clash after a reckless bet, mixing forced closeness, witty exchanges and genuine tenderness.
Buy on Amazon7. The Bodyguard
Katherine Center · €3.99
A bodyguard poses as a Hollywood heartthrob's girlfriend on a Texas ranch, combining forced proximity, plenty of humour and a sweetly guarded heart.
Buy on Amazon8. Role Model
Rachel Reid · €4.49
A grumpy hockey player and a cheerful social media manager slowly discover their attraction under public scrutiny, with playful banter and a warm, grounded feel.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 15 Nov 2026.