Books like The New Friend
The New Friend is a tense, unsettling story about trust and secrets, so these picks lean into twisty reveals and creeping unease. Each one offers that same sense that someone close may not be who they seem.
1. Verity
Colleen Hoover · $17.99
A ghostwriter's unnerving discovery in an isolated house builds dread through an unreliable voice and a final turn you will not see coming.
Buy on Amazon2. Every Little Lie
Dandy Smith · $6.99
Old secrets resurface through threatening messages, and the narrator's guilt keeps you questioning what she is hiding until the last pages.
Buy on Amazon3. None of This Is True
Lisa Jewell · $14.99
A true crime podcaster's life is upended by a mysterious stranger, with a sly, unreliable narration that keeps the unease simmering.
Buy on Amazon4. It’s Not What You Think
Clare Mackintosh · $4.99
A suspicious wife's search for the truth turns into something darker at home, with a domestic setting full of tension and sharp reversals.
Buy on Amazon5. This Room Has Eyes
Ty Hutchinson · $6.99
An old unsolved mystery returns to a dormitory room, blending a locked-room puzzle with an atmosphere of unease and buried history.
Buy on Amazon6. One Left Behind
Carla Kovach · $4.99
A teenage survivor's suspicion that a friend is lying gives this story the same fraught, fragile friendship dynamic and slow-building dread.
Buy on Amazon7. The Fury
Alex Michaelides · $16.99
Guests trapped on a remote Greek island face a deadly threat, with a claustrophobic setting and a twist that reframes everything.
Buy on Amazon8. Brie
Red Phoenix · $3.99
A quiet neighbourhood hides a woman's double life, and the creeping sense that secrets will not stay buried is very much in The New Friend's spirit.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated Nov 21, 2026.