Books like Eight Enchanting Elixirs
If you loved the playful witchy charm and small-town mischief of this cozy mystery, these picks offer similar warmth, humour and a dash of the supernatural. They range from village sleuthing to paranormal romps, so you can choose your favourite flavour of trouble.
1. A Body in the B&B
Katie Marsh · $0.99
Estranged sisters inherit a B&B and must solve a murder, with the cosy small-town setting and light, funny tone you enjoy.
Buy on Amazon2. Tea? Coffee? Murder! - A Deadly Fortune
Ellen Barksdale · $7.99
Two amateur sleuths poke into odd goings-on at a remote cottage, delivering the gentle, tea-and-clues atmosphere of a cosy whodunit.
Buy on Amazon3. We Chase Shadows
Richard Osman · $18.99
A witty team chases a note-leaving killer across two continents, mixing sharp banter with the brisk, clever puzzle-solving of a cosy mystery.
Buy on Amazon4. Split Second: Thirty-Two Switcheroo
Janet Evanovich · $20.99
A newly married, wisecracking heroine tangles with a bail jumper and a stalker, bringing comic chaos and a spirited female lead.
Buy on Amazon5. A Ghost of a Chance
Cherie Claire · $0.99
A psychic travel writer helps restless spirits in New Orleans, blending ghostly intrigue, humour and a touch of eeriness.
Buy on Amazon6. My Big Fat Supernatural Wedding
Sherrilyn Kenyon, Charlaine Harris, Jim Butcher & P.N. Elrod · $1.99
Nine paranormal authors share playful stories full of vampires, werewolves and witches, capturing the cheeky supernatural fun you enjoyed.
Buy on Amazon7. When an Alpha Growls
Eve Langlais · $4.99
A ranger and a flirtatious shapeshifter team up on a search, with shifter antics, banter and a lighthearted romantic edge.
Buy on Amazon8. There Are No Giant Crabs in This Novel
Jason Pargin · $21.99
Three quirky small-town misfits investigate a bizarre mystery, with offbeat humour and an unsettling, supernatural undercurrent.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated Nov 13, 2026.