Books like It's Different This Time
Here is a selection of contemporary romances that share the warm tension, witty banter and second chances of It's Different This Time. Each pick brings a different angle on proximity, old history and slowly rekindled feeling.
1. Not Just for Christmas
Cathy Bramley · $12.99
Two old friends reconnect over an unexpected invitation, and the cosy, heartfelt tone and history between them will feel familiar and comforting.
Buy on Amazon2. Pike
Brenda Rothert · $7.99
A wary single mum and a hockey goalie clash and bicker before real feelings take hold, with the same playful friction you enjoyed.
Buy on Amazon3. Love Story
Lindsey Kelk · $6.99
A secretive romance author and a cocky creative director are forced into close quarters, delivering sharp humour and a steady build of attraction.
Buy on Amazon4. The Bodyguard
Katherine Center · $4.99
A bodyguard pretends to be a Hollywood heartthrob's girlfriend at a Texas ranch, mixing fake dating, warm humour and a heart that gets very involved.
Buy on Amazon5. Role Model
Rachel Reid · $4.99
A grumpy hockey player and a cheerful social media manager slowly discover their attraction, with a gentle emotional pull and relatable workplace tension.
Buy on Amazon6. The Mistake
Elle Kennedy · $12.99
A hockey star who lost his chance with a freshman spends his final year trying to win her back, combining regret, banter and a determined second chance.
Buy on Amazon7. Keeping Jennifer
Susan Stoker · $9.99
A search-and-rescue expert and an Army pilot are thrown together and finally confront their feelings, with tension, emotional depth and a shared history.
Buy on Amazon8. Momentous, A Quantum Novel
Marie Force · $10.99
A film star's co-star declares his love mid-tour, leaving her to untangle what's real, with a light, funny tone and forced closeness that suits the mood.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 13 Nov 2026.