Books like Icebreaker
These picks lean into hockey and sports romance, with rivals and neighbours who are forced together and slowly become something more. Each one balances playful banter with the sizzling tension you enjoyed in Icebreaker.
1. Time to Shine
Rachel Reid · $4.99
Roommates who are friends first, a shy goaltender and a laid-back teammate, with warm humour and a slow shift from friendship into romance.
Buy on Amazon2. Pike
Brenda Rothert · $7.99
A wary single mum and a hockey goalie trade clashes and banter, with a reckless bet that tips into genuine feelings and plenty of cheeky humour.
Buy on Amazon3. The Deal
Elle Kennedy · $12.99
A campus hockey captain and a tutoring arrangement that becomes a pretend date, delivering quick wit, rivalry and rising heat.
Buy on Amazon4. Play Along
Liz Tomforde · $12.99
A pretend marriage between a team trainer and a baseball shortstop, with a cheeky, sporty setup and a steady build of chemistry.
Buy on Amazon5. Funny Story
Emily Henry · $15.99
Two opposites pretend to date after sharing an ex, and the playful, witty act gradually becomes uncomfortably real.
Buy on Amazon6. Hooking Hannah
Cassandra Carr & Cindy Carr · $2.99
A hockey player wins over a sister's reluctant rival, with sparkling chemistry, banter and a warm focus on trust and commitment.
Buy on Amazon8. Deep End
Ali Hazelwood · $12.99
Two athletes at Stanford start a secret arrangement that grows into something far more than a fling, with sharp rivalry and tension.
Buy on Amazon
Automatic selection based on the bestseller charts and each book’s description. Updated 16 Nov 2026.